VII. Reloading Information

C. Manufacturers

1. Dedicated Systems

a. "A Report on the Dedicated Systems Electronic Scale and and Powder Dribbler System"

by Chris Luchini (luchini@scrye.com)

[Maintainer] Note: Dedicated Systems has apparently gone bankrupt - please see VII.C.1.b. for more information.

Dedicated systems can be reached at 1-800-729-2808.
The cost for the combined system is $225, while just the scale
goes for about $160. They have a 30 day 'no questions asked'
money back policy. 

-------------

The scale comes with a 500 grain check weight, has a 1500 grain
upper limit, two powder pans, a 'training cup', and can be 
battery operated. It has a LCD read out to
.01 grains, and includes a number of interesting software options.

We investigated the precession of the scale by repeatedly weighing
a set of RCBS check weights, and recording the results.
We weighed one 200 grain , two 100 grain, one 50 grain, one
5 grain, one 1 grain and one .5 grain check weight. Each one was weighed
5 times.

The deviations from the mean for each weight was entered into a
histogram, and the RMS deviation was calculated. (we do this because
we have no way of knowing that the check weights are in fact the
nominal claimed values)

The RMS deviation over all measurements was .043 grains. If the trials
with the .5 grain check weight were eliminated, the RMS deviation was
.038 grains. The trials with the .5 grain check weight showed large
variations. The documentation warns that the software in the scale
will probably not weight items below .2 grain with any degree of
accuracy. From these measurements we made, we suggest that weights
below 1 grain are probably suspect, in the default software mode. The
software has something called 'tracker' mode which tries to 
compensate for thermal variations by recalibrating the scale's  zero
every time you remove the weight from the pan, and also tracks the
variation of the weight (due to thermal noise, air movement, or
whatever). There are software switches that allow only zero tracking,
or no tracking at all. With the default tracker mode, if you manually
dribble small amounts of powder, each grain of powder falling will/may
be interprited as thermal noise, and the weight will be recalibrated
to ignore the added weight of the powder as it is added. We believe
that this tacker mode is responsible for the larger than expected
variations of the 1/2 grain weight test.

The scale was also tested for off-of-center weight measurement
variations. We found a ~+-.5 grain extreme variation in a 1500 grain weight
from one side to the other of the scale pan. The scale was found to be 
very off balance, about 1 bubble on a small carpenters level. 
When we leveled the scale to ~1/5 bubble, the weight variations 
across the scale were reduced to about ~+-.1 grain. 

The powder dribbler hooks via a ribbon cable into the back of the
scale. It has a hopper that has about a 1 # capacity for 4198. The
scale must be trained to operate each type of powder, this takes about
5 min, and about 1/4-1/2 # of powder. Up to 9 types of powder training
parameters can be stored in the scale. We tested Red Dot and IMR 4198.
Both powders were dribbled to within .05 grain accuracy. Charge
weights of 80 grains of 4198 took about 15-18 seconds to dribble,
while 3 grains of Red Dot took under 10 seconds. The scale will
indicate a error condition if the dribbled weight is more than .1
grain out of tolerance.

The scale also has the feature that you can define a  'nominal'
weight, and high and low limits on that nominal weight, so that
you can sort bullets by weight class, or check for over/under
powder charge on loaded ammunition. There is no provision for
parts counting. 

In summary, our recommendation on this scale is "Buy it". With the
powder dribbler it is cheaper than dealer price on a RCBS electronic
scale, and offers all of the features that one could reasonably
want, and then some.

[Maintainer: I was a bit confused about whether the 'software'
 mentioned was internal to the scale or was something that ran on
 a PC & contacted Chris. Apparently the software is all internal
 to the scale, but there is a unexplained port on the back of
 scale which has no known use (maybe downloading new SW?)]