There is one thing we all definitely need when shooting: Ear protection. For most people, for years, this has usually been cheap, disposable earplugs. In fact, many products we call “cheap” today were much better than those used in the past. I have also used over-ear headphones from time to time; frankly, they are usually a bit more successful at blocking sound.
In this article, I have brought together 5 electronic ear protectors in different price ranges and segments; I have evaluated them in detail under headings such as sound blocking performance, comfort, material quality, sound quality, and price/performance.
Best Electronic Protection Models
Bocom Tech Praia (Cheapest Option)
This model is strictly a price-performance product. The two headphones work completely independently of each other; there is no cable between them. Each earcup has a separate volume control knob.
As an interesting detail, the buttons on the two headphones do not turn in the same direction; while turning one up, you might be turning the other down. It takes some getting used to, but it can’t really be called ergonomic.
Pros: Large and deep ear cushions Cons: Poor material quality, bad sound experience
Caldwell E-Max Low Profile
This model offers the classic electronic headset design. It automatically suppresses sounds above approximately 85 dB. Ambient sound is completely muted at the moment of firing.
Features:
- On/off and volume adjustment are done via buttons
- Simple to use
- Over-ear structure
Pros: Balanced performance for its price Cons: Buttons may cause problems in the long run
Howard Leight Impact Sport (Honeywell)
This model is seen as a reference product by many shooters.
Features:
- Control via rotary knob (dial)
- On-off and volume adjustment are very fast
- Intuitive usage
In terms of sound quality, it transmits ambient sounds more clearly and cleanly. Conversations sound more natural, and unnecessary noises are less prominent. Additionally, it saves battery life thanks to its automatic shut-off feature after 4 hours.
Pros: Very good sound quality, sturdy structure Cons: Plain design (may not appeal to those looking for visuals)
Walker’s Razor (Patriot Edition)
The Walker’s Razor series offers a wide price range with different versions. The version I reviewed is around $60.
Features:
- Material quality is quite good
- The outer surface is matte and durable
- Maintains its sturdiness even in long-term use
Sound quality is very close to the Caldwell and Howard Leight models. However, the fact that it completely shuts off ambient sound when music or external audio is connected may be a disadvantage for some users.
Pros: Durability, stylish design Cons: Ambient sound shuts off during external audio use
Walker Silencer (In-Ear – Premium Option)
This model is completely different from classic over-ear headphones. It offers in-ear electronic protection and has the highest noise reduction rating (NRR) on paper.
Features:
- Fits inside the ear like a foam earplug
- The most comfortable option for long-term use
- Separate volume control for each ear (but directions are consistent)
Box Contents:
- Carrying case
- Battery replacement tool
- Spare batteries
- Neck strap
Pros: Best comfort, high sound blocking Cons: Very expensive compared to others
Performance Tests – Real Usage Experience
Sound Cutting (NRR)
All models protect ears from damaging levels during firing. None of them caused ringing in the ears.
Comfort
- Most comfortable: Walker Silencer (in-ear)
- Over-ear models can apply pressure over long periods
- Interestingly, the cheapest model (Bocom Tech) turned out to be quite comfortable due to its ear structure.
Material Quality
- Bocom Tech: ⭐ (very weak)
- Caldwell: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Howard Leight: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Walker’s Razor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sound Quality
- Worst: Bocom Tech
- Medium: Walker Silencer (disadvantage of being in-ear)
- Good: Caldwell
- Very Good: Howard Leight
- Best Overall Balance: Walker’s Razor & Howard Leight
Which One Should You Buy? Clear Recommendations
Budget Focused: Caldwell E-Max → Affordable entry into the world of electronic headsets
Best Price / Performance: Howard Leight Impact Sport → The balance of sound quality, ease of use, and durability is very good
Design & Durability: Walker’s Razor → If appearance and sturdiness are important
Hunting and Long-Term Use: Walker Silencer → Ideal for those prioritizing comfort, but expensive
I Would Not Recommend: Bocom Tech Praia → It makes more sense to turn off the electronic feature and use it passively